- Home
- The...
The ‘original sin’ in Pharmally deal
Like a fish caught by the mouth, former health secretary Francisco Duque III revealed what many had already guessed, but dared not say: that former president Rodrigo Duterte had ordered the transfer of P47.6 billion from the coffers of the Department of Health (DOH) to the Procurement Service of the Department of Budget and Management (PS-DBM), supposedly to procure COVID-19 supplies at the height of the pandemic.
As bombshells go, it wasn’t exactly earth-shattering, but one that gave clarity to lingering questions on the political firestorm that rocked the country two years ago. That fateful order—a presidential directive as it now appears—was the “original sin” believed to have set the stage for the anomalous deal of plunderous proportions.
The presidential order allowed a little-known company called Pharmally Pharmaceutical Corp., with a paid-up capital of P625,000, to corner pandemic contracts worth billions of pesos as facilitated by PS-DBM. All told, Pharmally would secure, between March 2020 and July 2021, deals that totaled P11 billion to supply DOH with personal protective equipment sets, face masks, face shields, COVID-19 test kits, and other medical items.
Categorical statement
Duque made his disclosure during the June 3 oversight hearing of the House appropriations committee. Said Duque: “Publicly, the order to transfer funds from [DOH to PS-DBM] was made by the President in our weekly meetings or Talk to the People [program].”
It was the first categorical statement from any official, past or present, that linked the former president to the transfer of health funds to PS-DBM, headed then by former budget undersecretary Lloyd Christopher Lao.
But it wasn’t the first time such a claim was made.
On Feb. 1, 2022, the draft committee report released by then Sen. Richard Gordon who chaired the Senate blue ribbon panel, had stated that Duterte “admittedly ordered the transfer of P42 billion of DOH funds to PS-DBM for the purchase of supplies for use against COVID-19.”
The claim, however, had no solid footing, since it was predicated on Duterte’s admission on Aug. 31, 2021, that he ordered Duque to skirt established bidding processes. “I was the one who said, ‘I am sure there is a law which would exempt you from bidding’,” the former president had said. Duterte had never otherwise confessed to his role in the transfer of funds, until his health secretary let the cat out of the bag two years later.
Hasty clarification
On June 4, however, Duque hastily tried to take back his revelation by issuing a clarification that he had been “regrettably taken out of context” in media reports.
Yet there was no denial in his words, only empty justifications. In fact, Duque’s concluding sentence only reaffirmed what he had told the House panel earlier—that Duterte “gave his approval to course the procurement of said items through the PS-DBM.”
Duque’s ambivalence is not surprising, torn as he must be between the obligation to defend his former boss, and the instinct to protect his own hide.
Recall that on May 8 this year, the Office of the Ombudsman named Duque and Lao as respondents in a graft complaint in connection with what the Ombudsman described as the “illegal transfer” of some P41.46 billion in funds from the DOH to PS-DBM from March to December 2020, presumably the same amount linked to Duterte’s order. The Ombudsman’s resolution said Duque and Lao “acted with evident bad faith or gross, inexcusable negligence,” with their wrongdoing “highlighted by the fact that the illegal fund transfers occurred amid a national health emergency where respondents were expected to be more prudent and diligent in handling people’s money.”
Though not quite a smoking gun, Duque’s disclosure swung the culpability in his former boss’ direction, under the principle of command responsibility.
Forgetfulness as excuse
When asked about Duque’s admission, all the former president could say was he couldn’t remember. “Maybe what I said is, ‘go ahead’,” one newspaper report quoted him as saying. “I could not recall, for the life of me. Maybe what you are saying is true.”
Such excuse is nothing new for Duterte, so it is now up to the Ombudsman to compel him to recall his exact role in the still unraveling Pharmally scandal. Was he complicit or only negligent since the grossly disadvantageous contracts were consummated under his nose?
Then again, would Ombudsman Samuel Martires, a Duterte appointee, find the gumption to indict the former president for the same offenses his office had ruled against Duque and Lao?
The bigger question: Would the Marcos administration run after Duterte and make him accountable, as earlier governments had done by filing plunder cases against former presidents Joseph Estrada and Gloria Macapagal Arroyo? Or, like scores of other untouchables, would the former president be spared the wages of sin in the interest of politics?
- https://www.msn.com/en-ph/news/other/the-original-sin-in-pharmally-deal/ar-BB1nYd2O
Related
China Is Paying People Extra To Dump Their Gas Cars
It's a good time to be an EV shopper in China. Yes, even more than usual.
NewsHow BINI’s historic appearance at KCON LA 2024 will promote P-pop’s rise
The continuous rise of BINI has reached new heights after they made history as the first P-pop group to grace KCON LA 2024, a three-day concert and convention featuring the biggest acts and rising stars of K-pop. BINI is included in KCON LA’s lineup as a performer for the pre-show of the “M Countdown” stage on Saturday, July 27. They will also be part of the convention in a special “Meet the Rising Stars: BINI” panel the day after. This is a...
NewsPCE release, Apple's Chinese sales, European earnings - what's moving markets
Investing.com -- Wall Street looks set to end a difficult week on a bright note, although the release of the Federal Reserve's favorite inflation gauge later in the session could influence sentiment. Apple is losing market share in the important...
NewsFrom Manila to France, South Sudan eyes victory beyond basketball
KIGALI—”Bigger than basketball.” After qualifying for the Olympics for the first time, South Sudan’s basketball team is on a mission to make their troubled young country proud. The players come from the United States, Australia, Canada, some starting out life in refugee camps. They know little about their country, as their parents fled during the Sudan conflict of 1983 to 2005, one of the longest civil wars on record, that eventually paved the...
NewsMajor attack on French TGV network: here's what we already know
French high-speed train (TGV) services will be "very disrupted" over the coming weekend, following "a large-scale attack" to cripple the high-speed network. And the timing could not be worse as the Olympics kick off in Paris this weekend. Several attacks were carried out on train stations in France during the night from Thursday to Friday. These included deliberate arson with the clear aim of crippling high-speed train traffic. French railway...
NewsChina gave the world Covid-19; PH spreading 'Philippinization' in politics?
First word PRACTICALLY everyone in the world knows now that the Philippines is the biggest thorn in China's extravagant claim of sovereignty over all of the South China Sea, including our exclusive economic zone, or the West Philippine Sea. What is baffling is the news which is borne out by the archives of The Manila Times that our country appears also to have bequeathed a disease to the world, just as China lacerated and tormented the world...
NewsChina welcomes POGO ban in the Philippines
(UPDATES) THE Chinese Embassy in the Philippines has taken note of President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.'s decision to ban all Philippine offshore gaming operators (POGOs), and stated that the move would benefit Filipinos and the Chinese. "We have noted President Marcos' announcement of banning all POGOs and welcome this development. We believe this decision echoes the call of the [Filipinos] and serves the common interests of the peoples of both...
NewsMakati City takes down 'Gil Tulog' signs
The Makati City government has taken down “Gil Tulog Avenue” signs that replaced street signs along Gil Puyat Avenue for a supposed advertising campaign. In a statement Friday, Mayor Abby Binay apologized to the family of late Senate president Gil Puyat and said she had already reprimanded the city officials who greenlighted the said campaign. “It is unfortunate that the request for a permit for the so-called advertising campaign to change the...
News