- Home
- California...
California House Passes 'Passive Speed Limit' Bill But It Likely Won't Curb Accidents
If cars are on the table, how long before motorcycles are added?
Look, I'm all for safety. I'd rather not see anyone hurt in a car or motorcycle accident. But there are times when our state and federal governments miss the forest for the trees in terms of new laws.
Good intentions, bad implementation.
Case in point, California's House just recently passed a bill that would require all new cars sold by 2032 to come from the factory with "passive speed limiters." The Bill—Senate Bill 961—was introduced by Senator Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco), and sponsored by the organizations CalBike, Streets For All, Streets are for Everyone, KidSafe SF, and Walk SF, as well as supported by the National Transportation Safety Board, American Academy of Pediatrics, and AAA. These are well-intentioned folks.
And as for the language, the Bill states, "This bill would require 50% of certain vehicles, commencing with the 2029 model year, to be equipped with a passive intelligent speed assistance system, as specified, that would utilize a brief, one-time, visual and audio signal to alert the driver each time the speed of the vehicle is more than 10 miles per hour over the speed limit. The bill would require all specified vehicles, commencing with the 2032 model year, to be equipped in the above-described manner."
There's no mention of motorcycles in the text, however. I know, I checked twice.
Now, the Bill's advocates rightly point out that speeding is a serious issue. A lot of good people are hurt or killed each year because drivers are going faster than ever before. And the Bill, as written now, won't impact your ability to speed, as it requires tech to "warn drivers with audible and visual signals when they exceed the speed limit by greater than ten miles per hour." There's no changing to what your inputs are, whichfollows the recent push for these passive speed limiters in Europe, too.
Speaking on the passing of the Bill in the House, Senator Wiener stated, “California, like the nation as a whole, is seeing a horrifying spike in traffic deaths, with thousands of drivers, cyclists, and pedestrians dying each year on our roads. These deaths are preventable, and they’re occurring because of policy choices to tolerate dangerous roads. The evidence is clear: Rising levels of dangerous speeding are placing all Californians in danger, and by taking prudent steps to improve safety, we can save lives. I thank my colleagues for their support.”
Again, he makes a lot of good points. But for me—and this is a personal opinion—I feel like we're just putting a band-aid on an open gash while annoying a whole sect of your electorate.
What's the actual point?
I ask that question, as yes, installing some sort of tech to help remind folks to stop speeding is a simple and easy potential solution. But the underlying issues of why people speed, and the dangers of modern automobiles, as well as driver inattention, aren't being addressed by this bill.Nor is the lack of driver training here in the U.S.
See, I've been driving cars since I was well under the legal age to operate a motor vehicle...allegedly. And I've been riding motorcycles nearly as long. I've driven in large cities like Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, and European cities, as well as small towns. And through it all, I've watched people's ability to operate these increasingly heavier and heavier vehicles drastically diminish over time. People aren't as good at driving as they once were, and while the cars have gotten safer for those within them, they've gotten heavier, faster and fuller of tech that distracts us from the act of driving.
Hello, Hummer EV.
Speeding, however, is just a symptom of one of the problems we face as motorists, one that also includes a lack of sufficient self-care time so we're left always rushing. Yes, this Bill might reduce traffic deaths, but we already have Blind-Spot Monitoring, Automatic Emergency Braking, as well as a suite of collision alarms in our new cars, and accidents still happen. Fatalities still occur. Cars still can't see motorcyclists, either. And an alarm isn't going to matter much in reducing the overall accident and fatality statistics.
Passing this band-aid of a bill, however, would be much easier to campaign on. At least, that's what I'd say as a political cynic.
What is good for the time being is that this proposed Bill hasn't been made into law yet, nor would it impact your ability to drive faster than the posted speed limit. It also doesn't affect motorcycles as written. Again, I checked. Twice.
But even this type of proposed legal language can impact everyone later on and our ability to drive our machines how we want. Now I'm not advocating for everyone to start speeding. And I think more folks should pay attention to posted speed limits, especially given so few new and current drivers are properly trained to handle the sort of power their modern cars or motorcycles are putting down.
There's a whole separate blog I could write about our extremely lackluster licensing system, too.
Yet, passing this Bill into law won't solve anything except for pissing a lot of people off. It's basic voter lip service when these same politicians could be advocating for better driver training, better road conditions, better working conditions for the average worker, and more.
But hey, I don't have to get re-elected to keep my power.
Politicians Gonna Politician
- New Jersey's 'No Fault Insurance' Law Leaves Scooters In Limbo
- Helmets Might Not Be the Scam We’re Led To Believe
- https://www.msn.com/en-au/news/other/california-house-passes-passive-speed-limit-bill-but-it-likely-won-t-curb-accidents/ar-BB1mSlqr?ocid=00000000
Related
‘Complete dud’: Matt Canavan and Abigail Boyd go head-to-head in heated net zero debate
Nationals Senator Matt Canavan and NSW Greens MP Abigail Boyd have gone head-to-head in a debate about whether Australia should scrap its net zero target.
NewsSix earthquakes hit Southern California in one week. Does that mean ‘The Big One’ is coming?
Six earthquakes hit Southern California in one week. Does that mean ‘The Big One’ is coming? - Earthquakes remain confoundingly difficult to predict, according to experts, even though many are desperately trying to figure out the best way to handle big quake in a state encountering around 35 a day, writes Josh Marcus
NewsPop, Paris and poetry: The wild dreams of Cody Simpson
The self-proclaimed Prince Neptune is chasing an Olympic berth, but time is running out.
NewsKey global powers fail to sign Ukraine’s peace summit communique
Key regional powers including Brazil, India, South Africa and Saudi Arabia have failed to sign up to a joint communique issued at the end of a Ukraine peace conference in which more than 80 countries and international organisations endorsed its territorial integrity in the face of Russia’s invasion. Speaking at the end of the two-day summit in Switzerland, Ukraine’s president Volodymyr Zelenskiy, welcomed the “first steps toward peace” but...
News‘Stay away’: Barnaby Joyce urges businesses not to play politics after Voice defeat
Former deputy prime minister Barnaby Joyce has slammed Qantas for supporting the Indigenous Voice to Parliament referendum.
NewsKids Keep Eating Magnets, And Surgeons Say There's Only 1 Way to Stop It
Toy magnets pose a serious risk for young children, even when parents are supervising playtime. According to new research, set to be presented by emergency medicine specialist Leah Middelberg of Nationwide Children's Hospital, the number of kids requiring emergency surgery to remove neodymium magnets is not falling, in spite of attempts to highlight the dangers. It seems, the researchers conclude, that the only way to prevent kids eating magnets...
NewsJack has been to hell and back. Now, finally, she will be an Olympian
Even on a Sunday in mid-2024, when Shayna Jack’s drug ordeal is behind her and she will soon board a plane to Paris, the subject is still enough to draw tears.
NewsThird Form of Life Makes Energy in 'Remarkable' Ways, Scientists Discover
As the world turns to green hydrogen and other renewable energy sources, scientists have discovered that archaea – the third form of life after bacteria and eukaryotes – have been making energy using hydrogen gas and 'ultraminimal' enzymes for billions of years. Specifically, the international team of researchers discovered that at least nine phyla of archaea, a domain of single-celled organisms lacking internal membrane-bound structures,...
News